5 things in a small shop's ads and store that were costing it orders
I looked at the shop's active ads in Meta's public Ad Library, then went through the store the way someone clicking one of those ads would. Everything here was visible without a login. I didn't see their sales or ad numbers, so I can say where the path breaks, not how many dollars each fix is worth.
- An active ad invited custom orders, while the store's banner said custom requests were closed until January.
- The ads pitched gifts for teachers, and the teacher piece was sold out.
1. The ad offered custom pieces. The store said "not until January."
What I sawA live ad, running for weeks, invited people to have a piece made to order. The banner across the top of every page of the store said custom requests were closed until January.
Why it costs ordersThe shop was paying for the click of someone who wanted a custom Christmas gift, and the first thing that person read on arrival was that they couldn't have one. Some browse the stock pieces. Many leave, and the click is paid for either way.
The fixUntil requests reopen, pause that ad or change its last line to something the shop can deliver now, like "over 100 handmade pieces in stock and ready to ship." Bring the custom line back in January.
2. The ads said "gifts for teachers." The teacher piece was sold out.
What I sawThe gift ads named who the pieces are for, teachers first. In the catalogue, about 1 in 10 pieces were sold out, including the teacher piece and several other popular occupations.
Why it costs ordersTeacher gifts are one of the biggest reasons people buy a small present in December. The ad plants the idea, the buyer searches the store for "teacher", and lands on a sold-out page.
The fixRestock those first if possible before the Christmas cut-off. If not, add a "back in January, email me" button on each sold-out piece so the visit still turns into a contact, and take the sold-out occupations out of the ad wording until they return.
3. The top banner was about what people couldn't have
What I sawThe banner at the top of every page was the custom-request notice from point 1, with a couple of stray formatting characters. Meanwhile the product pages already showed an estimated delivery date, which is excellent and most shops don't have.
Why it costs ordersThe banner is the most-read line on the site. In the weeks when almost every visitor is a gift buyer, it was announcing a closed door instead of the one thing they all want to know: will it arrive in time?
The fixUntil the cut-off, make the banner: "In stock and ready to ship. Order by [date] for Christmas delivery." Move the custom-request notice to the custom page and the FAQ.
4. About 1,800 reviews, sitting a long way down the page
What I sawThe homepage had a reviews section, but it sat sixth, below the gift guide, a family note, the best sellers and another block. None of the ads I read mentioned the number.
Why it costs ordersThat many reviews is rare for a family workshop. It answers every first-time visitor's question ("is this real, and is it any good?") faster than anything else on the page, and it was doing that job from the middle of a long scroll.
The fixOne line directly under the main headline: "Rated by 1,800+ customers", with the stars. Add the same line to the ads. It costs nothing and it's true.
5. Many of the ads were the same ad
What I sawAround 30 ads were running. Of the 17 I read, several were a year old or more, and the same opening line appeared on ads started months apart.
Why it mattersAn old ad that still sells should keep running, and only the owner can see which ones do. But when most ads say the same thing in the same words, you learn very little about what else might work.
The fixKeep the proven ads. Alongside them, test three new angles, one ad each: the material and where it's made, a specific person ("for the coach who has everything"), and the proof (the review count). Run them for two weeks and keep whichever beats the current best.
What was already good
- A product nobody else makes.
- An estimated delivery date on every product page.
- Reviews on the product pages, with real customer names.
- A holiday gift guide already on the homepage.
What the full $99 audit adds
This was a free look at what anyone can see from outside: the store's public pages and 17 of its ads. The full audit goes further:
- Your ads' actual results, if you give me view-only access to your ad account. No login of yours is needed.
- Every ad you're running, not a sample.
- A test order through checkout.
- Your welcome and abandoned-cart emails.
- Every page checked on a phone, where most of your shoppers buy.
If they did only two things this week
Pause or reword the custom-order ad (point 1), and change the top banner to their Christmas order-by date (point 3).
Faisal Shah, Larkstone Growth